Knock Detection

The Battle Against Knock – Blog Post #1: A Silent Threat and the Achilles’ Heel of High-Performance Engines

Posted by author-avatar
On May 26, 2025
0 comments
Welcome to our new blog series on engine knock and knock detection—an essential knowledge hub for performance tuners, engine builders, and calibration professionals. Across these articles, we dive deep into what engine knock really is, why it’s such a critical threat in modern high-performance engines, and how advanced detection methods can safeguard your builds.
What to Expect: From knock fundamentals to combustion science to sensor placement,ECU vs.standalone detection systems,unique cases like rotary and UAV engines — each article builds your knowledge step by step.

Blog Post #1
The Silent Threat: Why Knock is the Achilles’ Heel of High-Performance Engines

You’ve invested thousands into your engine. Forged pistons, CNC-ported heads, high-boost turbochargers, and a state-of-the-art ECU calibration. Everything is ready to deliver mind-blowing power — until, somewhere in the power–band, you hear a faint metallic rattle. It could be fleeting, maybe unnoticed over the roar of the exhaust. Yet, it could spell disaster. Welcome to the world of engine knocking combustion.

What is Knock, Really?

Knock is uncontrolled combustion that happens when the air-fuel mixture ignites spontaneously ahead of the flame front initiated by the spark plug. Instead of a smooth, controlled burn, knock creates shock waves that travel rapidly inside the combustion chamber. These pressure spikes can severely damage pistons, spark plugs, and bearings — especially when left unchecked.
When knock occurs, what actually happens is that the remaining unburned air-fuel mixture—called the end-gas—spontaneously ignites due to rising pressure and heat from the advancing flame front. This sudden, uncontrolled combustion creates a shockwave that resonates inside the cylinder. That pressure wave then bounces off the chamber walls and transfers vibration through the cylinder head and block—what we ultimately detect using knock sensors. It’s not just uncontrolled ignition—it’s chaotic combustion echoing violently through the engine structure.

Not All Knock Is Equal: Beware of Super Knock

While mild knock might only cause surface-level piston damage over time, super knock is an entirely different beast. This violent form of combustion typically originates from pre-ignition — when the air-fuel mixture ignites before the spark plug fires, usually due to a hot spot in the combustion chamber or leftover burning particles from a previous cycle.
This can happen during rev limiter conditions, where partial ignition or fuel cut strategies leave unburned fuel in the chamber.

During super knock a much larger percentage of the available air fuel mixture spontaneously ignites, resulting in very large pressure spikes typically 100–150% above normal. Super knock isn’t just “more knock”; the additional mechanical stress can easily result in broken pistons, bent connecting rods, even cracked cylinder walls.

Once super knock hits, it’s often too late—the engine doesn’t get a second chance. Remember: It’s not just a severe form of knock — it’s a catastrophic event.

Real-life example of a super-knock event captured with the PLEX PCA-2000Plus® combustion analysis system.

Why Knock is Such a Problem

You might wonder: if knock is so short-lived, why is it so destructive? It all comes down to heat, pressure, and repetition.

Knock doesn’t just create pressure spikes — it increases localized temperatures dramatically. Even if a single event doesn’t melt or crack a piston, repeated knock cycles often lead to heat-induced stress fractures, broken ring lands, or even complete piston failure.

“In knocking conditions, the flame front propagates at extremely high speeds — often exceeding 500 to 1000 m/s — breaking down the thermal boundary layer and generating destructive pressure waves across the combustion chamber.”

One underappreciated factor is how knock alters heat transfer. Normally, a thin insulating boundary layer of gas—called the laminar layer—protects the piston crown from direct heat. During knock, this layer gets stripped away by the violent turbulence, allowing much more combustion heat to reach the piston. This doesn’t just raise local temps—it can start melting the crown or deforming the piston edges. This is why knock damage often shows up as localized aluminum erosion or scuffing, even before a piston cracks.

Is Knock Always Audible?

Experienced tuners often use audio detection — either from the ECU or a standalone knock monitor — to listen for knock. It often sounds like a faint metallic ping or click, especially under heavy load or throttle.

Even trained ears can miss knock when mechanical noise is high—especially in engines with solid lifters, direct injection clatter, or loud intake resonance. That’s where smart audio DSP (digital signal processing) steps in. By filtering out irrelevant frequencies and isolating the knock band, modern knock monitors make knock clearly audible even in very noisy environments. It’s not just about hearing—it’s about hearing the right thing, at the right time.

Still, not all knock is audible — and not all audible events are knock. Therefore, combining audio, log data, and sensor input is essential for accurate diagnosis.

Real-life example of a unfiltered, knock-audio signal captured with the PLEX Knock Monitor V3®.

The Knock Avalanche

One knock event can be damaging enough — but the real danger lies in its self-reinforcing nature. Each knock cycle increases local piston and combustion chamber temperatures, degrading the thermal boundary layer that normally insulates surfaces from combustion heat. As this protective layer collapses, the piston crown absorbs more heat, making the unburned end-gas even more prone to auto-ignition in the next cycle.

This creates a vicious feedback loop: knock leads to higher surface temperatures, which in turn increase the likelihood of further knock. On pump fuels with limited detonation resistance, this runaway effect can escalate rapidly, especially under sustained load or high intake air temperatures. In contrast, high-octane race fuels provide a larger margin before detonation occurs, offering tuners a buffer when pushing for higher output.

This is why knock is rarely an isolated event. It cascades — and once it begins, damage accumulates fast.

“That’s why modern professional knock detection systems that log event count or knock intensity per cycle are so useful. They don’t just tell you knock happened — they help you catch trends. If you start seeing consistent knock events on a specific cylinder or under repeatable conditions (e.g. heat soak laps), that’s a warning sign of a detonation feedback loop in progress. Recognizing this escalation early is key to avoiding failure — especially on pump fuel.”

⚠️ Unexpected Truth: Knock Can Increase Power (Temporarily)

Here’s something few tuners openly acknowledge: under certain conditions, mild knock can actually raise power output — at least in the short term.

This phenomenon occurs because engines that are “knock-limited” are unable to operate at their optimal spark timing — known as MBT (Minimum spark advance for Best Torque). Instead, ignition timing is intentionally retarded to prevent knock, resulting in combustion that occurs slightly later than ideal. This reduces peak cylinder pressure and shifts the pressure curve away from the piston’s most mechanically advantageous point (typically around 12–16° after top dead center).

Allowing a small amount of knock — whether intentional or not — brings the average combustion phasing closer to MBT. The result is a higher indicated mean effective pressure (IMEP) and, therefore, a temporary gain in torque and power. In essence, the engine becomes more efficient cycle-to-cycle, extracting more work from the combustion process.

However, this comes at a price. Even mild knock introduces sharp pressure oscillations that increase mechanical stress and thermal loading on pistons, bearings, and head gaskets. These spikes, though brief, can cause cumulative damage over time — especially under sustained high load or elevated intake air temperatures.

From a thermodynamic standpoint, the gain arises not because knock improves combustion, but because the engine is no longer being “held back” by conservative ignition retardation. The performance increase is the result of operating closer to the ideal phasing — with knock simply acting as a dangerous byproduct of that advance.

In professional tuning environments, the goal is not to eliminate all knock at any cost, but to identify where the true knock threshold lies — and then calibrate safely just below it using high-resolution knock detection tools. The art lies in maximizing output while preserving engine integrity.

Real-World Case Study: Knock in a Track-Built Turbocharged 4G63

In a well-known case from the tuning community, a Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution 8 running 28 psi of boost on a built 4G63 engine began suffering from faint but persistent knock. It wasn’t audible over the turbo and exhaust noise on track, but post-session inspection revealed fractured ring lands on two pistons — classic detonation damage. The factory ECU knock sensor failed to intervene, as the knock signals were masked by the engine’s high-frequency vibrations and background mechanical noise.

Only after reviewing data from a standalone knock detection system did the tuning team uncover the issue. Subtle knock events had occurred consistently at high load, especially during heat-soaked laps. Had the team relied solely on the ECU’s onboard system, they would have missed it — and likely faced a complete engine failure in the sessions that followed.

Key Takeaways

  • Knock isn’t just noise — it’s uncontrolled combustion that can destroy engines in seconds.

  • It’s caused by spontaneous ignition of unburned end-gas, leading to damaging pressure waves.

  • High-compression and forced induction engines are especially vulnerable, even with safe-looking AFRs.

  • Not all knock is audible — especially in noisy race environments or under high mechanical load.

  • One knock event can trigger more: it’s a cascading phenomenon, not an isolated glitch.

  • Modern detection tools with DSP and per-cylinder analysis are essential for tuning safely and precisely.

Coming Up Next: Combustion 101 — How Engines Burn Fuel and Where It Can Go Wrong

In our next article, we’ll go deeper into combustion dynamics, how knock differs from pre-ignition, and how engineers and tuners design engines to mitigate it. Stay tuned!

Newer Reimagining an Icon: The 1998 Twin-turbo Lotus Esprit V8-GT by Doob Technology in Girona – SPAIN
Back to list
Older Winning The Battle Against Knock — A Deep-Dive Blog Series for Data-driven Tuners & Engine Builders